SUPREME COURT DECISIONS/RESOLUTIONS
AFFECTING COA

 


Supreme Court Case Digests

CY 2004
Supreme Court Decisions/Resolutions

CY 1994

CY 1993

CY 1992

 




 


 

2004 SUPREME COURT CASE DIGESTS:

CA-G. R. SP No. 80568 - November 26, 2004

Commission on Audit vs. Hon. Judge Ricardo R. Rosario, RTC, Branch 66, Makati City, and the Association of Guarantee Fund for Small and Medium Size Enterprises Employees (AGE), namely Melvin Abanto, et al

G. R. No. 157001 - October 19, 2004

Home Development Mutual Fund represented by its acting President and Chief Executive Officer, Atty. Romero Federico S. Quimbo, Petitioner vs. Commission on Audit represented by the Chairman, Guillermo N. Carague, Respondent

G. R. No. 156982 - September 8, 2004

National Amnesty Commission, Petitioner, vs. Commission on Audit, et al, Respondents

G. R. No. 150769 - August 31, 2004

Kapisanan ng  mga Manggagawa sa Government Service Insurance System (KMG), Petitioner, vs. Commission on Audit, Guillermo N. Garague, in his capacity as Chairman, Commission on Audit, et. al, Respondents

A. M. No. P-02-1626 - July 27, 2004

Complaint Against Atty. Wilfredo B. Claveria for Misappropriation of Judiciary Funds

A. M. No. 01-11-291-MTC - July 7, 2004

Initial Report on the Financial Audit Conducted in the Municipal Trial Court of Pulilan, Bulacan

G. R. No. 142297 - June 15, 2004

Home Development and Mutual Fund, Petitioner, vs. Commission on Audit, Respondent

G. R. No. 147392 - March 12, 2004

Benedicto Ernesto R. Bitonio, Jr., Petitioner vs. Commission on Audit and Celso D. GANGAN, Chairman of the Commission on Audit, Respondents

G. R. No. 144516 - February 11, 2004
Development Bank of the Philippines vs. COA
G. R. No. 156641 - February 5, 2004

Rodolfo S. De Jesus, Edelwina DG. Parungao, Primo T. Lomibao and Alice Marie C. Osorio, Petitioners vs. Commission on Audit, Respondents

G. R. No. 147402 - January 14, 2004
Engr. Ranulfo C. Feliciano vs. COA, et al.
G. R. No. 138598

Asset Privatization Trust vs. Sandiganbayan (5th Div) and Rosario M.B. Olivares

 


 

 

SUPREME COURT DECISIONS/RESOLUTIONS:

CY 1994

G. R. No. 104217 - December 5, 1994

Manila International Airport Authority, Petitioner vs. Commission on Audit, Respondent

Re:

Disallowance, Additional allowances; Payment of Representation and Transportation Allowance (RATA). 238 SCRA 714

G. R. No. 106611 - July 21, 1994

Commissioner of Internal Revenue, Petitioner vs. Court of Appeals, Citytrust Banking Corporation and Court of Tax Appeals, Respondents

Re:

Tax Refund; Taxpayer cannot be entitled to tax refund and at the same time be liable for a tax deficiency assessment for the same year

G. R. No. 107016 - March 11, 1994

Development Bank of the Philippines, Vivencio Macapagal, Alfredo Casal, Eduardo Mendoza, Adoracion Garcia, Rodel Magnayon, Rosario Elep, Ma. Antonio Rebueno, Jose Rivera, M. Sapalicio and G. Rojas, Petitioners vs. Commission on Audit, Respondent

Re:

Power of COA to post-audit pre-audited transactions. 213 SCRA 202

G. R. No. 98355 - March 2, 1994

Francisco S. Tantuico, jr., Petitioner vs. Hon. Eufemio Domingo, in his capacity as Chairman of the Commission on Audit, Estelito Salvador, Margarito Silot, Valentina Eustaquio, Anicia Chico and Germiniano Pasco, Respondents

Re:

Contract; Compromise Agreement; Certificate of Availability of Funds; Government contract entered into without certification as to availability of funds; void. 230 SCRA 595

G. R. No. 96422 - February 28, 1994

Francisco S. Tantuico, jr., Petitioner vs. Hon. Eufemio Domingo, in his capacity as Chairman of the Commission on Audit, Estelito Salvador, Margarito Silot, Valentina Eustaquio, Anicia Chico and Germiniano Pasco, Respondents

Re:

Withholding of retirement benefits; Retirement pay accruing to a public officer may not be withheld and applied to his indebtedness to the government. 230 SCRA 391

G. R. No. 110936 - February 4, 1994

Francisco A. Tan, Jr., Petitioner, vs. Office of the President, Renato C. Corona, in his capacity as Assistant Secretary for Legal Affairs, Office of the President, Department of Agriculture, Commission on Audit, and Andres R. Menguito, Respondents.

Re:

Payment of back salaries to dismissed civil servant who is ultimately exonerated and ordered reinstated to his former or equivalent position. 229 SCRA 677

 



 

CY 1993

G. R. No. 109046 - November 25, 1993
Gunting Z. Medsep vs. Commission on Audit, et al.
Re:

Administrative Law; dismissal from service; reinstatement; claim for back salaries

G. R. No. 112318 - November 23, 1993
Clodualdo Z. Reyes vs. Consolacion Song and The Honorable Commission on Audit
Re:

Administrative Law; dismissal from service; reinstatement; claim for back salaries

G. R. No. 104646 - October 19, 1993

Dr. Lylia Corporal-Sena, President, Camarines Sur Polytechnic Colleges vs. Commission on Audit

Re: Grant of honoraria
G. R. No. 100284 - October 13, 1993

Narciso E. Mamaril, Petitioner vs. Hon. Eufemio C. Domingo, In his capacity as Chairman, Commission on Audit (COA), Respondent

Re: Negligence; withholding of terminal leave pay
G. R. No. 75025 - September 14, 1993

Vicente Garcia, Petitioner, vs. The Honorable Chairman Commission on Audit, The Honorable Minister Land Transportation and Communications, The Regional Director, Telecom Regional Office No. IV, Respondents

Re:

Payment of back salaries of a dismissed employee; reinstatement by reason of executive clemency. 226 SCRA 356

G. R. No. 104539 - September 2, 1993

Braulio S. Dayday vs. Hon. Bartolome S. Carale, as Chairman of the National Labor Relations Commission, and Hon. Eufemio C. Domingo, as Chairman of the Commission on Audit

Re:

Claim for Representation and Transportation Allowance (RATA); Reinstatement with Back Salaries

G. R. No. 101370 - September 2, 1993

National Housing Corporation, Petitioner, vs. Commission on Audit and Arturo D. Dadufalza, in his capacity as COA Director, Technical Services Office, Respondents

Re: Hiring of Foreign Consultants. 226 SCA 55
G. R. No. 101452 - August 12, 1993

Western-Visayas Medical Center Employees Association, et. al. vs. Commission on Audit

Re: Payment of Subsistence Allowance
G. R. No. L-45998 - February 4, 1993

Crisanto B. Amores, Petitioner vs. Acting Chairman Commission on Audit, The Provincial Treasurer and Provincial Auditor of Misamis Occidental, Respondents

Re:

Retirement Law; Additional allowance received as honorarium by a Municipal Judge from the Municipality cannot be included in the computation of his retirement benefits. 218 SCRA 227

G. R. No. 103578 - January 29, 1993

Administrative Law; Terminal Pay; Commutation of Leave Credits; Provision of the Revised Administrative Code as amended limiting the accumulation of total vacation leave and sick leave to not exceeding ten months or 300 days. 218 SCRA 409

Re:

Retirement Law; Additional allowance received as honorarium by a Municipal Judge from the Municipality cannot be included in the computation of his retirement benefits. 218 SCRA 227

G. R. No. 101976 / G.R. No. 102258 - January 29, 1993

The Commissioner of Internal Revenue, Petitioner, vs. The Commission on Audit, Respondent / Tirso B. Savellano, Petitioner, vs. The Commission on Audit, Respondent

Re:

Jurisdiction of COA on Tax Informer's Reward. 218 SCRA 203

 



 

CY 1992

G. R. No. 103982 - December 11, 1992
Antonio A. Mecano, Petitioner vs. COA
Re:

Medical and hospitalization expenses; Section 699, Revised Administrative Code. 216 SCRA 500

G. R. No. 100773 - October 16, 1992

Philippine Ports Authority and Rogelio A. Dayan, Rufino l. Tan, Nora A. Buenviaje, for their own and in behalf of some 289 PPA officials and supervisors, Petitioners vs. COA, et al.

Re:

Administrative Law; Salary Standardization Law; Payment of Representation and Transportation Allowance (RATA) after the effectivity of Republic Act No. 6758 (Salary Standardization Law of 1989). 214 SCRA 653

G. R. No. 75959 - August 31, 1992
Victoriano V. Orocio, Petitioner vs. COA, et al.
Re: Refund of Hospitalization Expenses; Quasi-delict. 213 SCRA 109
G. R. No. 96628 - July 3, 1992
Ceferino Inciong vs. Honorable Eufemio Domingo, Chairman, Commission on Audit
Re: Payment of attorney's fees. 211 SCRA 139
G. R. No. 92279 - June 18, 1992

Edmundo C. Sambeli, doing business as ECS Enterprises, Petitioners, vs. Province of Isabela, Provincial Treasurer of Isabela and Commission on Audit, Respondents

Re:

Constitutional law; impairment of contract; contract of sale; overpricing. 210 SCRA 80

G. R. No. 92585 - May 8, 1992

Caltex Philippines, Inc. Petitioner vs. The Honorable Commission on Audit, Honorable Commissioner Bartolome C. Fernandez and Honorable Commissioner Alberto P. Cruz

Re:

Oil companies' claim for reimbursement from the Oil Price Stabilization Fund (OPSF) created under P.D. 1956, as amended. 208 SCRA 726

G. R. No. 97351 - March 17, 1992

Ramon A. Gonzales vs. Hon. Francisco I. Chavez, etc., Presidential Commission on Good Government and Commission on Audit

Re:

Hiring of private lawyers by the Office of the Solicitor General to prosecute PCGG cases. 205 SCRA 876

G. R. No. 91860 - January 13, 1992

Roseo U. Tejada and Radito C. Ching, Petitioners, vs. Hon. Eufemio C. Domingo, in his capacity as Chairman of the Commission on Audit, Respondent

Re:

Claim for additional allowances under R.A. 6758 (Salary Standardization Law). 205 SCRA 138

 

 

| General Information About COA | Human Resource Management Information |
| Rules and Regulations | Annual Financial Reports | Fraud Alert | COA News |
| Annual Audit Reports | GWSPA Reports | COA Decisions |
| SC Decisions/Resolutions Affecting COA | COA Bids and Awards |
| What's New | Government / Other Links | Technical Services Data Center | Home |


For your comments or suggestions about this website,
please send e-mail to  coaweb@coa.gov.ph or cweb@pacific.net.ph
Revised and Maintained by COAWEB Center
Copyright © 1999-2008 Commission on Audit. All Rights Reserved.